The Master's Guide to Lapis Lazuli Color: Sourcing the Deepest 'Ultramarine' Blue

By Reza Piroznia, FCGmA

I am Reza Piroznia, FCGmA—Master Artisan, Certified Gemmologist. Part of our Ultimate Lapis Lazuli Guide. Exploring lapis lazuli's color characteristics and its geological significance provides essential context, which is thoroughly covered in our master guide to Lapis Lazuli that encompasses all aspects of this gemstone.

Lapis Lazuli: A Historical Overview and Significance

Lapis Lazuli, derived from the Latin "lapis" (stone) and the Persian "lazward" (blue), has a history as rich and vibrant as its color. Its use dates back to the 7th millennium BC, unearthed in ancient burial sites in Mehrgarh, Pakistan. The ancient Egyptians revered it, associating it with the sky, royalty, and the afterlife. Think of Tutankhamun's iconic death mask, adorned with Lapis; or the eyebrow pencils used by Cleopatra, ground from this precious stone. The Sumerians, Babylonians, and Minoans all held Lapis in high esteem, using it for jewelry, amulets, and decorative objects. It traveled the Silk Road, making its way to Europe, where it became prized by Renaissance artists.

The use of Lapis extended beyond mere adornment. Ground into a pigment, it yielded the highly sought-after Ultramarine blue, a color so expensive and rare that it was reserved for the most important elements in paintings, often the robes of the Virgin Mary. The cost stemmed from the laborious process of extraction and the significant distance the raw material had to travel from its primary source in Afghanistan. Even today, high-quality Lapis commands a premium, a testament to its enduring appeal and historical significance.

Composition and Formation of Lapis Lazuli

Lapis Lazuli is not a single mineral, but rather a rock composed of several minerals, primarily lazurite, sodalite, haüyne, and nosean. Lazurite, with the chemical formula $(Na,Ca)_8(AlSiO_4)_6(SO_4,S,Cl)_2$, is the key component responsible for the distinctive blue color. The presence and proportion of these other minerals, along with inclusions like pyrite (iron sulfide, $FeS_2$) and calcite ($CaCO_3$), significantly influence the overall appearance and value of the stone.

The formation of Lapis Lazuli is a metamorphic process, typically occurring in contact metamorphic zones where limestone or marble is altered by the intrusion of igneous rocks. During this process, high temperatures and pressures, coupled with the introduction of sulfur-rich fluids, lead to the crystallization of lazurite and the associated minerals. The specific geological conditions necessary for the formation of gem-quality Lapis are relatively rare, which contributes to its scarcity and value.

Understanding the mineral composition and formation process is crucial for identifying and evaluating Lapis Lazuli. While the presence of lazurite is essential for the blue color, the other minerals and inclusions play a vital role in determining the overall quality and desirability of the stone. For example, excessive amounts of calcite can dilute the blue color, while pyrite inclusions, when present in moderation and aesthetically pleasing, can add to the stone's character and value.

The Color Conundrum: Dissecting the 'Ultramarine' Blue

The most sought-after color in Lapis Lazuli is undoubtedly the deep, intense 'Ultramarine' blue. This color is characterized by its rich saturation, even distribution, and lack of undesirable undertones. Achieving this ideal color is a complex interplay of factors related to the lazurite content, the presence and distribution of other minerals, and the overall geological context of the Lapis deposit.

The intensity of the blue color is directly proportional to the concentration of lazurite. Stones with a high lazurite content exhibit a deeper, more saturated blue than those with a lower concentration. However, the purity of the lazurite itself is also important. Impurities within the lazurite crystal structure can affect the color, potentially leading to grayish or greenish undertones. Furthermore, the particle size of the lazurite crystals can influence the perceived color. Finer-grained lazurite tends to produce a more uniform and intense blue than coarser-grained lazurite.

The presence of other minerals, particularly calcite and pyrite, can significantly impact the color of Lapis Lazuli. Calcite, being white, dilutes the blue color, making the stone appear paler and less vibrant. Excessive calcite is generally considered undesirable, although some specimens with interesting calcite patterns can be aesthetically pleasing. Pyrite, on the other hand, can add visual interest to the stone. Small, evenly distributed pyrite inclusions can create a sparkling effect, enhancing the overall beauty of the Lapis. However, large or clustered pyrite inclusions can detract from the stone's value, especially if they obscure the blue color.

Geographic Origins: Afghanistan and Beyond

While Lapis Lazuli is found in various locations around the world, including Chile, Russia, and the United States, the finest specimens, particularly those exhibiting the coveted 'Ultramarine' blue, originate from the Sar-e-Sang mines in the Badakhshan province of Afghanistan. These mines have been the primary source of Lapis for thousands of years, and the quality of the Lapis from this region remains unmatched.

The Sar-e-Sang mines are located in a remote and rugged mountainous region, making access and extraction challenging. The Lapis deposits occur within metamorphic rocks, typically marble, and are associated with skarn zones. The geological conditions in this region are particularly favorable for the formation of high-quality Lapis, characterized by a high lazurite content, minimal calcite, and aesthetically pleasing pyrite inclusions.

Lapis from other locations, while potentially beautiful and valuable, often differs in color, composition, and overall quality compared to Afghan Lapis. For example, Chilean Lapis tends to be lighter in color and may exhibit greenish or grayish undertones due to the presence of sodalite and other minerals. Russian Lapis, from the Lake Baikal region, can be quite dark, sometimes approaching a deep indigo color. Understanding the geographic origin of Lapis is crucial for accurately assessing its value and quality. As an FCGmA professional, I often use detailed visual inspection under magnification, coupled with spectroscopic analysis, to help determine the origin with a high degree of confidence. This is critical when valuing antique pieces where provenance information might be limited.

Grading Lapis Lazuli: The FCGmA Standard and Beyond

Grading Lapis Lazuli is a complex process that takes into account several factors, including color, texture, the presence and distribution of inclusions, and the overall quality of the polish. While there is no universally accepted grading system for Lapis, the FCGmA promotes a standardized approach based on these key criteria. My personal system, developed over years of experience, aligns closely with the FCGmA guidelines and emphasizes a holistic assessment of the stone's beauty and value.

Color: This is the most important factor in grading Lapis Lazuli. The ideal color is a deep, intense 'Ultramarine' blue, with even distribution and no undesirable undertones. Stones with a lighter blue color, or those with grayish or greenish undertones, are generally considered less valuable. The saturation and tone of the blue color are carefully assessed to determine the grade.

Texture: The texture of Lapis Lazuli refers to the uniformity and consistency of the mineral composition. Stones with a fine-grained, homogeneous texture are generally preferred over those with a coarse or uneven texture. The presence of large or irregular patches of calcite or other minerals can detract from the stone's beauty and value.

Inclusions: The presence and distribution of inclusions, particularly pyrite and calcite, can significantly impact the grade of Lapis Lazuli. Small, evenly distributed pyrite inclusions can add visual interest and enhance the overall beauty of the stone. However, large or clustered pyrite inclusions can detract from the stone's value. Excessive calcite is generally considered undesirable, although some specimens with interesting calcite patterns can be aesthetically pleasing. The FCGmA standard prioritizes minimizing visual distractions from inclusions that detract from the overall color and beauty.

Polish: The quality of the polish is essential for maximizing the brilliance and beauty of Lapis Lazuli. A well-polished stone will exhibit a smooth, lustrous surface, free from scratches or other imperfections. The polish should be even and consistent across the entire surface of the stone.

In the next section, we will delve into specific techniques for sourcing Lapis Lazuli, focusing on ethical considerations, identifying treated stones, and navigating the complexities of the international market.

The Master's Guide to Lapis Lazuli Color: Sourcing the Deepest 'Ultramarine' Blue - Part 2

By Reza Piroznia, FCGmA

Welcome back! In Part 1, we explored the historical significance, composition, and formation of Lapis Lazuli, focusing on the coveted 'Ultramarine' blue and its geographical origins. Now, we move to the practical aspects of sourcing this precious gemstone, covering ethical considerations, identifying treated stones, and navigating the complexities of the international market. My goal is to equip you with the knowledge and insights to confidently acquire Lapis Lazuli that meets your specific needs and expectations.

Ethical Sourcing: A Responsibility We Share

The beauty of Lapis Lazuli should not come at the expense of ethical practices. As consumers, we have a responsibility to ensure that the gemstones we purchase are sourced responsibly and sustainably. This means supporting suppliers who adhere to fair labor standards, respect environmental regulations, and contribute to the well-being of the communities where Lapis Lazuli is mined. Unfortunately, the Lapis Lazuli trade, particularly in regions like Afghanistan, can be fraught with challenges, including conflict financing and human rights abuses.

Here are some key considerations for ethical sourcing:

• Traceability: Seek suppliers who can provide information about the origin of their Lapis Lazuli. While complete traceability is often difficult to achieve, asking questions and demanding transparency can help to ensure that the stone was not sourced from conflict zones.
• Fair Trade Practices: Support suppliers who adhere to fair trade principles, ensuring that miners and local communities receive a fair price for their goods.
• Environmental Responsibility: Inquire about the environmental practices of the mining operations. Responsible mining minimizes environmental damage and promotes sustainable practices.
• Certifications: Look for certifications from reputable organizations that promote ethical sourcing and responsible mining practices. While specific Lapis Lazuli certifications are rare, broader gemstone industry certifications can provide a degree of assurance.

Due diligence is paramount. Ask your suppliers questions, research their reputation, and be prepared to pay a premium for ethically sourced Lapis Lazuli. By supporting responsible practices, we can help to ensure that the Lapis Lazuli trade benefits both the industry and the communities involved.

Identifying Treated Lapis Lazuli: Separating the Authentic from the Enhanced

Like many gemstones, Lapis Lazuli can be subjected to treatments to enhance its color or appearance. These treatments range from simple waxing and oiling to more complex dyeing and impregnation techniques. While some treatments are relatively harmless and discloseable, others can significantly alter the stone's appearance and value, making it crucial to identify them accurately. Understanding these treatments is essential for making informed purchasing decisions.

Common Lapis Lazuli Treatments:

• Waxing and Oiling: These treatments involve applying a thin layer of wax or oil to the surface of the stone to improve its luster and fill minor surface imperfections. Waxing and oiling are generally considered acceptable, as they are temporary and do not significantly alter the stone's composition.
• Dyeing: Dyeing is used to enhance the blue color of Lapis Lazuli, particularly stones with a pale or uneven color. Dyes can penetrate the porous structure of the stone, imparting a more saturated and uniform blue hue. Dyed Lapis Lazuli is typically less valuable than natural, untreated stones with a similar color.
• Impregnation with Polymers or Resins: This treatment involves impregnating the stone with polymers or resins to improve its durability, reduce porosity, and enhance its color. Impregnation can make the stone more resistant to scratches and damage, but it can also alter its appearance and value.
• Reconstitution: Lower quality materials are held together with resin to mimic the look of high-quality Lapis Lazuli.

Identifying Treated Lapis Lazuli:

• Visual Inspection: Carefully examine the stone under magnification for signs of dye concentration in cracks and crevices. Dyed Lapis Lazuli may also exhibit an unnatural or overly uniform color.
• Hot Point Testing: A hot point testing tool (use with caution as you may damage the stone), may show waxy residue on a waxed stone.
• Acetone Test: Gently wipe the stone with a cotton swab dampened with acetone. If the swab picks up a blue color, it may indicate the presence of dye. Be careful, as this can damage the stone if acetone soaks in.
• Microscopic Examination: A microscope can reveal the presence of dyes, polymers, or resins within the stone's structure.
• Spectroscopic Analysis: Advanced techniques like Raman spectroscopy can be used to identify the presence of dyes or other foreign substances in Lapis Lazuli.

Always ask your supplier about any treatments that the Lapis Lazuli has undergone. Reputable suppliers will disclose all known treatments. If you are unsure, seek the opinion of a qualified gemologist. Always be wary of stones being sold at prices that are "too good to be true".

Navigating the International Market: Tips for the Discerning Buyer

The international market for Lapis Lazuli can be complex and challenging, with variations in quality, price, and ethical standards. Here are some tips for navigating the market and sourcing high-quality Lapis Lazuli:

• Establish Relationships with Reputable Suppliers: Building long-term relationships with trusted suppliers is crucial for sourcing high-quality Lapis Lazuli. Look for suppliers with a proven track record of ethical sourcing, transparent pricing, and reliable service.
• Attend Gem and Jewelry Shows: Gem and jewelry shows provide an opportunity to see a wide variety of Lapis Lazuli from different sources and to meet with suppliers in person.
• Visit Mining Regions: For the adventurous buyer, visiting mining regions like Afghanistan can provide a firsthand look at the Lapis Lazuli extraction process and an opportunity to source stones directly from the miners. However, this approach requires careful planning, cultural sensitivity, and a strong understanding of the local market conditions.
• Utilize Online Resources: Online marketplaces and trade directories can provide access to a wide range of Lapis Lazuli suppliers. However, exercise caution when buying online and always verify the supplier's reputation and credentials.
• Negotiate Prices: Be prepared to negotiate prices, especially when buying in bulk. Research the current market prices for Lapis Lazuli to ensure that you are getting a fair deal.
• Verify Authenticity and Quality: Always verify the authenticity and quality of Lapis Lazuli before making a purchase. Use the identification techniques discussed earlier in this guide and seek the opinion of a qualified gemologist if necessary.

'The Master's Bench'

Here's a quick reference table for identifying key properties of Lapis Lazuli:

Property	Value
Refractive Index	1.500 - 1.508
Mohs Hardness	5 - 6
Specific Gravity	2.7 - 2.9

Reza’s Authentication Tip

Over the years, I've learned to trust my instincts when it comes to Lapis Lazuli. One trick I use to quickly assess a stone is to examine it under strong, diffused light. Look for subtle variations in the blue color and the distribution of pyrite. Natural Lapis rarely has a perfectly uniform color; there will be slight gradations and nuances. Uniform, overly saturated blue, especially in combination with evenly distributed (often brassy) pyrite, is a big red flag for me. It often indicates dyed or reconstituted material. Also, pay attention to the feel of the stone. Genuine Lapis tends to have a slightly waxy feel to the touch, while imitation materials can feel smoother or even plastic-like.

Final Thoughts: The Enduring Allure of Ultramarine

Sourcing the deepest 'Ultramarine' blue in Lapis Lazuli requires knowledge, patience, and a commitment to ethical practices. By understanding the stone's history, composition, and potential treatments, and by building relationships with reputable suppliers, you can confidently acquire Lapis Lazuli that meets your specific needs and expectations. The enduring allure of this gemstone, with its rich history and vibrant color, continues to captivate us today, just as it has captivated artists and royalty for millennia.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

1. Eastaugh, Nicholas, et al. Pigment Compendium: A Dictionary of Historical Pigments. Routledge, 2008.
2. Hurlbut, Cornelius S., and Cornelis Klein. Manual of Mineralogy. 21st ed., John Wiley & Sons, 1993.
3. Nassau, Kurt. Gemstone Enhancement. Butterworth-Heinemann, 1994.
4. Newman, Renée. Gemstone Buying Guide: How to Evaluate, Negotiate, and Select Diamonds, Colored Gems, Pearls & Gold. International Jewelry Publications, 2014.
5. Reza Gem Collection Research Lab. Lapis Lazuli Treatment and Identification. Unpublished Internal Report, 2022.

---