Moonstone Quality: A Gemmologist's View on Color, Clarity, and Cat's Eye Effect

I am Reza Piroznia, FCGmA—Master Artisan, Certified Gemmologist. Part of our Ultimate Moonstone Guide. Understanding moonstone's color characteristics characteristics is essential for proper evaluation, and this detailed analysis complements the foundational knowledge in our master Moonstone guide.

This guide represents a portion of my accumulated knowledge, focusing specifically on the critical aspects of moonstone quality: color, clarity, and the elusive cat's eye effect. We will explore these characteristics through the discerning eye of a gemmologist, highlighting the nuances that separate the ordinary from the exceptional.

The standards I employ in assessing moonstone, and indeed all gemstones, are firmly rooted in the FCGmA principles of rigorous examination and ethical practice. Adherence to these principles is paramount for ensuring accurate identification, valuation, and ultimately, building trust within the gemstone community.

What is Moonstone? A Brief Overview

Moonstone is a member of the feldspar group, specifically the orthoclase series, with the chemical formula $(Na,K)AlSi_3O_8$. While often thought of as a single mineral, moonstone can also include albite (sodium-rich feldspar) and oligoclase (sodium-calcium feldspar) which contribute to the adularescence that it is known for. It’s this shimmering effect, reminiscent of moonlight on water, that gives moonstone its enchanting name and enduring appeal.

The name "adularescence" is derived from Mount Adular in Switzerland, a historical source of high-quality moonstone. While Mount Adular is not the primary source of moonstone today, the term remains the definitive descriptor for its characteristic optical phenomenon.

It's important to remember that not all feldspars exhibit adularescence. The presence of this effect, and its intensity, is crucial in identifying and grading moonstone.

Color: The Subtle Spectrum of Moonstone

Color is a significant factor in determining the value and desirability of any gemstone, and moonstone is no exception. While often associated with a milky white or bluish sheen, moonstone can exhibit a range of bodycolors and adularescence hues.

Bodycolor

The bodycolor refers to the inherent color of the moonstone material itself, viewed through the adularescence. Common bodycolors include:

• Colorless to White: These are the most prevalent. A colorless bodycolor allows the adularescence to shine through without interference, making it highly desirable when coupled with strong blue or vibrant sheen.
• Yellow to Brown: Often referred to as "Champagne Moonstone," these stones possess a warm, golden hue. The value is generally lower than colorless varieties exhibiting high quality adularescence.
• Gray: Gray moonstones can range from light to dark shades. The overall appeal depends on the intensity and color of the adularescence.
• Peach to Pink: These moonstones exhibit soft, romantic hues. The intensity of the color significantly affects their value, with deeper, more saturated pinks commanding a premium.
• Green: Green moonstones are rarer and often feature a subtle, muted green bodycolor.
• Brown to Black: These are generally of lower value, as the dark bodycolor can obscure the adularescence.

Adularescence Color (The Sheen)

The adularescence is the star of the show, the mesmerizing optical effect that defines moonstone. This shimmering light results from the interference of light as it passes through the alternating layers of orthoclase and albite within the gem's structure. The thinner and more regular these layers, the finer and more vibrant the adularescence will be.

The most sought-after adularescence colors are:

• Blue: Blue adularescence, particularly a vibrant, electric blue, is considered the most valuable and desirable. This is often referred to as "blue sheen" or "blue flash." The intensity and coverage of the blue sheen are critical factors in determining its value.
• Silver: A silvery-white adularescence is also common and can be quite attractive, especially when exhibiting a strong, shimmering effect.
• Rainbow: "Rainbow Moonstone" is actually a variety of labradorite, another feldspar mineral, that exhibits iridescence, a play of multiple colors across the surface. While often marketed as moonstone, gemmologically it is distinct. The quality of rainbow moonstone is determined by the vibrancy and range of colors displayed. We'll cover this more extensively in a separate guide, but it's important to clarify the distinction here.
• Other Colors: Occasionally, you may encounter moonstones with hints of yellow, green, or even pink in their adularescence. These are less common but can be quite appealing depending on the overall aesthetic.

When evaluating the color of moonstone, I always consider the following:

• Intensity: How strong is the bodycolor and the adularescence? A vivid bodycolor combined with a bright, eye-catching adularescence is generally more valuable.
• Purity: Is the color clean and free from undesirable tints or overtones? A clear, pure blue sheen is preferred over a muddy or grayish blue.
• Coverage: How evenly is the adularescence distributed across the surface of the stone? A uniform sheen is generally more desirable than a patchy or uneven one.
• Angle of View: The adularescence is often most pronounced when the stone is viewed from specific angles. A good quality moonstone will exhibit a strong sheen from multiple angles.

Clarity: Unveiling the Inner World of Moonstone

Clarity refers to the presence (or absence) of internal inclusions and surface blemishes within a gemstone. Moonstone, being a Type II gemstone (typically included), is often expected to have some inclusions. However, the type, size, and location of these inclusions can significantly impact its value and overall beauty.

The FCGmA standard dictates careful examination under magnification, typically 10x, to accurately assess clarity. We look for features that detract from the stone's beauty or compromise its structural integrity.

Common Inclusions in Moonstone

• Fractures: Fractures are breaks or cracks within the stone. They can affect the stone's durability and can also interfere with the adularescence, creating unwanted flashes or distortions.
• Needle-like Inclusions: These are thin, elongated inclusions that can be composed of various minerals. When abundant and oriented in a parallel arrangement, they can contribute to the cat's eye effect, which we'll discuss later.
• Pinpoint Inclusions: These are tiny, dot-like inclusions that can appear as a hazy cloud within the stone. While a few pinpoint inclusions are acceptable, a high concentration can reduce the stone's transparency and brilliance.
• Feather-like Inclusions: These inclusions resemble feathers or fingerprints and are typically composed of partially healed fractures.
• Mineral Inclusions: Small crystals of other minerals can be trapped within the moonstone during its formation.

Impact of Inclusions on Value

The impact of inclusions on the value of moonstone depends on several factors:

• Size and Number: Larger and more numerous inclusions will generally decrease the value of the stone.
• Location: Inclusions located near the surface of the stone are more noticeable and can also make the stone more susceptible to damage. Inclusions that obstruct the adularescence are particularly undesirable.
• Type: Some inclusions are more visually distracting than others. For example, dark, opaque inclusions are more noticeable than transparent ones.
• Impact on Durability: Fractures and large inclusions can weaken the stone and make it more prone to chipping or breaking.

Ideally, a moonstone should be as free from inclusions as possible, especially those that detract from its beauty or affect its durability. However, it's important to remember that perfectly flawless moonstones are rare. A skilled gemmologist can assess the impact of inclusions and determine their overall effect on the stone's value.

Moonstone Quality: A Gemmologist's View on Color, Clarity, and Cat's Eye Effect - Part 2

Continuing our exploration of moonstone quality, we now delve into the captivating cat's eye effect and practical identification techniques.

In Part 1, we established the importance of color and clarity in evaluating moonstone. We discussed the spectrum of bodycolors and adularescence hues, and the impact of inclusions on a stone's beauty and durability. Now, we turn our attention to a rarer phenomenon that can dramatically increase a moonstone's value: the cat's eye effect.

Cat's Eye Moonstone: A Gleaming Line of Light

The cat's eye effect, also known as chatoyancy (from the French "oeil de chat," meaning "cat's eye"), is an optical phenomenon that creates a bright, narrow band of light that appears to move across the surface of a cabochon-cut gemstone when it is rotated. In moonstone, this effect is caused by parallel, needle-like inclusions oriented within the stone. These inclusions act like tiny mirrors, reflecting light and creating the characteristic "eye."

The sharpness, brightness, and straightness of the cat's eye line are crucial factors in determining the quality and value of cat's eye moonstone. A well-defined, centered, and bright cat's eye is highly prized.

Formation of the Cat's Eye Effect

As mentioned earlier, the cat's eye effect in moonstone arises from the presence of numerous parallel inclusions. These inclusions are typically composed of minerals such as hematite, rutile, or even hollow tubes. The alignment of these inclusions is critical. If they are randomly oriented, they will not produce the desired effect.

During the formation of moonstone, these needle-like crystals align themselves perpendicular to the c-axis of the crystal structure. When a cabochon is cut with the base parallel to the inclusions, the light is reflected in a band across the dome, creating the cat's eye effect.

Evaluating Cat's Eye Moonstone

When assessing cat's eye moonstone, consider the following:

• Sharpness: The cat's eye line should be sharp and well-defined, not blurry or diffused.
• Brightness: The brighter the cat's eye line, the more desirable the stone.
• Straightness: The line should be straight and unbroken, extending across the entire dome of the cabochon.
• Centering: Ideally, the cat's eye line should be centered on the dome of the cabochon.
• Movement: The cat's eye line should appear to move smoothly and fluidly across the surface of the stone as it is rotated.
• Adularescence: The presence of adularescence, in addition to the cat's eye effect, can further enhance the beauty and value of the moonstone.

Cat's eye moonstone is generally rarer than moonstone without the effect, and high-quality specimens with a sharp, bright, and well-centered cat's eye can command a significant premium.

Distinguishing Moonstone from Imitations and Simulants

Unfortunately, the popularity of moonstone has led to the proliferation of imitations and simulants in the market. It is crucial for both consumers and professionals to be able to distinguish genuine moonstone from these fakes. While a full gemmological lab analysis is the most definitive method, several simple tests can help to identify moonstone.

Common moonstone simulants include:

• Opalite: This is a man-made glass that is often sold as moonstone. Opalite typically exhibits a uniform, milky appearance with a single, strong reflection, lacking the subtle variations and adularescence of genuine moonstone.
• Labradorite: While labradorite is a related feldspar mineral, it exhibits iridescence (a play of multiple colors) rather than adularescence (a single, shimmering color). As mentioned previously, it is sometimes sold as "rainbow moonstone."
• Plastic and Resin: These materials can be molded to resemble moonstone, but they lack the hardness and optical properties of the real gem.

Here are some quick tests you can perform to help differentiate genuine moonstone from simulants:

• Adularescence Test: Observe the stone under different lighting conditions and angles. Genuine moonstone will exhibit a distinct shimmering adularescence. Imitations often lack this subtle effect or have a uniform, unnatural sheen.
• Hardness Test: Moonstone has a Mohs hardness of 6 to 6.5. It can be scratched by a steel file but not by a copper penny. (Note: This test should be performed with caution as it can damage the stone.)
• Temperature Test: Genuine moonstone feels cool to the touch, while plastic and resin imitations tend to feel warmer.
• Magnification: Examine the stone under magnification (10x). Genuine moonstone may contain natural inclusions, while imitations may have bubbles or other artificial features.

Reza’s Authentication Tip: From my years of experience, I've found that examining the stone's interior under strong diffused lighting is incredibly revealing. Authentic moonstone almost always has subtle internal characteristics – faint feathery inclusions or a slight "milky" texture that disperses the light in a characteristic way. Synthetic materials often appear too perfect, too uniform, lacking that natural complexity. Also, the way the adularescence "rolls" across the surface as you tilt the stone is often more fluid and nuanced in genuine moonstone compared to the often static and uniform sheen of an imitation.

The Master's Bench: Gemmological Properties

For a more detailed gemmological identification, these are the values that should be checked:

Property	Value
Refractive Index	1.518 - 1.526
Mohs Hardness	6 - 6.5
Specific Gravity	2.56 - 2.59

Cutting and Polishing Moonstone

Moonstone is typically cut en cabochon to best display its adularescence or cat's eye effect. The orientation of the cut is crucial to maximize the beauty of these optical phenomena. For adularescence, the cabochon should be cut with the dome perpendicular to the layers causing the sheen. For cat's eye moonstone, the base of the cabochon should be parallel to the needle-like inclusions.

The polishing of moonstone requires a delicate touch. Because of its relatively soft nature, it is susceptible to scratches and chips. Fine abrasives and careful techniques are used to achieve a smooth, lustrous surface without damaging the stone.

Ethical Considerations and Sourcing

As with all gemstones, it is important to consider the ethical implications of moonstone sourcing. Ensure that the moonstone you purchase comes from reputable sources that adhere to fair labor practices and environmentally responsible mining techniques. Ask your suppliers about the origin of their stones and their commitment to ethical sourcing.

Conclusion

Moonstone, with its ethereal beauty and captivating optical phenomena, continues to enchant gem enthusiasts and jewelry designers alike. By understanding the key factors that influence its quality – color, clarity, and the elusive cat's eye effect – you can appreciate the nuances that separate the ordinary from the exceptional. Remember to always examine moonstone carefully, seeking the guidance of a qualified gemmologist when necessary, to ensure that you are acquiring a genuine and ethically sourced gemstone.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

1. Anderson, B. W. *Gem Testing.* 10th ed. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1987.
2. Hurlbut, Cornelius S., and Robert C. Kammerling. *Gemology.* 2nd ed. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1991.
3. Liddicoat, Richard T., Jr. *Handbook of Gem Identification.* 12th ed. Santa Monica, CA: Gemological Institute of America, 1989.
4. Nassau, Kurt. *Gemstone Enhancement.* 2nd ed. Boston: Butterworth-Heinemann, 1994.
5. Reza Gem Collection Research Lab. *Moonstone Grading Standards and Authentication Protocols.* Unpublished Internal Document, Toronto, Canada, 2023.

---