Moonstone in Jewelry: Investment Insights from a Master Goldsmith on Setting and Design

Part 1: Understanding the Lure and Lore of Moonstone

I am Reza Piroznia, FCGmA—Master Artisan, Certified Gemmologist. Part of our Ultimate Moonstone Guide. Understanding moonstone's historical significance and cultural impact requires a comprehensive foundation, which is provided in our master guide to Moonstone covering geology, color, and value.

Moonstone, a feldspar mineral with a captivating adularescence (the shimmering, billowy light that seems to float just beneath its surface), has captivated humanity for centuries. Its name, of course, speaks to its resemblance to the moon's soft glow, and ancient cultures often associated it with lunar deities and mystical properties. But beyond its romantic allure, moonstone presents a unique set of challenges and opportunities for the jeweler. Properly understood and skillfully handled, it can be transformed into investment-worthy pieces that appreciate not only in monetary value but also in sentimental significance.

The Geological Genesis of Moonstone

Before we delve into setting and design, it's crucial to understand the geological origins of moonstone. This understanding informs our appreciation for the stone's inherent characteristics and potential vulnerabilities.

Moonstone belongs to the feldspar group of minerals, specifically the alkali feldspars (orthoclase, albite, and microcline). Adularescence, the defining characteristic of moonstone, arises from a phenomenon known as *perthitic intergrowth*. This occurs when two feldspar minerals, typically orthoclase ($KAlSi_3O_8$) and albite ($NaAlSi_3O_8$), exsolve (separate) from a solid solution during cooling. These exsolved lamellae (thin, parallel layers) are of different refractive indices. As light enters the stone, it is scattered at these boundaries, producing the characteristic shimmering effect. The finer and more regular the lamellae, the more intense and desirable the adularescence.

While the above describes the most common type, it's important to recognize that other feldspars can also exhibit adularescence and be marketed as moonstone. These include:

• Rainbow Moonstone: Technically a variety of labradorite, another feldspar ($CaAl_2Si_2O_8$ to $NaAlSi_3O_8$). It displays a schiller effect, a broader iridescent play of color, rather than the singular, milky adularescence of true moonstone. While beautiful, it's crucial to distinguish it from true moonstone when assessing value.
• Adularia: A potassium-rich feldspar, considered by some to be the "true" moonstone. Fine quality adularia exhibits a bluish adularescence highly prized by collectors. Its chemical formula is $KAlSi_3O_8$.

Moonstone deposits are found in various locations around the world, including Sri Lanka, India, Myanmar (Burma), Madagascar, Tanzania, and the United States. The geographical origin can influence the color, clarity, and intensity of adularescence, and therefore, its value. Historically, Sri Lanka has been renowned for producing some of the finest quality moonstones with a captivating blue sheen.

Identifying Quality: The FCGmA Standard and Beyond

As an FCGmA, I adhere to a rigorous standard for verifying the authenticity and quality of gemstones, including moonstone. This involves a multi-faceted approach that incorporates visual inspection, microscopic analysis, and, in some cases, advanced gemmological testing.

When evaluating moonstone, consider the following factors:

• Adularescence: This is paramount. Look for a vibrant, floating light that appears to originate from within the stone. The color and intensity of the adularescence significantly impact value. Blue sheen is generally the most sought after, followed by silver and other hues. The adularescence should be visible from a wide range of viewing angles.
• Body Color: The ideal moonstone has a colorless to near-colorless body. This allows the adularescence to shine unimpeded. However, stones with subtle body colors, such as a light champagne or peach, can also be attractive, especially if the adularescence is exceptional.
• Clarity: Moonstone is rarely flawless. Inclusions are common, and some can even enhance the stone's character. However, large or dark inclusions that detract from the adularescence or compromise the stone's durability should be avoided. Small "centipede" inclusions (fine, parallel cracks) are relatively common and generally do not significantly affect value unless they are extensive.
• Cut: The cut is crucial for maximizing the adularescence. Cabochon cuts are the most common, as they best showcase the floating light effect. The cabochon should be symmetrical, well-polished, and free from significant blemishes. The height of the dome also affects the adularescence. A well-proportioned cabochon will exhibit a strong, even sheen across the entire surface.
• Size and Shape: Larger, high-quality moonstones are rarer and command higher prices. While round and oval cabochons are classic choices, moonstone is also found in a variety of other shapes, including freeform, pear, and cushion cuts. The choice of shape depends on the intended design and the natural characteristics of the stone.

Beware of imitations! Glass, synthetic spinels, and other materials can be used to mimic moonstone. Always purchase moonstone from a reputable source and, ideally, have it verified by a qualified gemmologist, particularly if you are investing in a significant piece.

Furthermore, the FCGmA standard emphasizes ethical sourcing. We must be mindful of the environmental and social impact of gemstone mining and strive to support responsible practices that benefit both the communities involved and the planet.

Durability Considerations

Moonstone, with a hardness of 6 to 6.5 on the Mohs scale, is relatively soft compared to other gemstones. This means it is susceptible to scratches and abrasions. This is a critical consideration when designing and setting moonstone jewelry.

Therefore, the design should minimize the stone's exposure to everyday wear and tear. Protective settings, such as bezels or partial bezels, are often preferred. Avoid designs where the moonstone is set flush with the surface of the jewelry, as this increases the risk of scratching.

Furthermore, moonstone is sensitive to heat and sudden temperature changes. Avoid exposing it to direct sunlight for prolonged periods or using harsh cleaning agents. Gentle cleaning with warm soapy water and a soft brush is the best approach.

Market Trends and Investment Potential

The demand for moonstone jewelry has fluctuated over time, but its timeless appeal ensures a consistent market. Factors influencing its price include:

• Rarity of High-Quality Stones: As with any gemstone, the scarcity of exceptional specimens drives up their value. Moonstones with strong blue adularescence, excellent clarity, and large size are particularly prized.
• Fashion Trends: The popularity of moonstone often aligns with broader fashion trends. For example, the resurgence of interest in bohemian and vintage styles has fueled demand for moonstone jewelry.
• Geopolitical Factors: Political instability or mining disruptions in major moonstone-producing regions can impact supply and, consequently, prices.
• Consumer Awareness: Educated consumers are more discerning and willing to pay a premium for high-quality, ethically sourced moonstones.

While moonstone may not offer the same level of speculative investment potential as, say, diamonds or colored gemstones like rubies or sapphires, it can still be a sound investment, particularly if you focus on acquiring well-made pieces featuring high-quality stones. A well-designed and crafted moonstone piece, especially one that showcases a rare and beautiful stone, can appreciate in value over time, both monetarily and sentimentally.

In the next part of this guide, we will delve into the practical aspects of setting moonstone, exploring various techniques and design considerations that ensure both the beauty and longevity of your creations. We will also discuss specific design strategies to maximize the adularescence and enhance the investment potential of moonstone jewelry.

Moonstone in Jewelry: Investment Insights from a Master Goldsmith on Setting and Design

Part 1: Understanding the Lure and Lore of Moonstone

Welcome, fellow artisans, aspiring gemmologists, and jewelry enthusiasts. I am Reza Piroznia, FCGmA—Master Artisan, Certified Gemmologist, and Fellow of the Canadian Gemmological Association. For over forty years, I’ve dedicated my life to the art of crafting exquisite jewelry, with a particular fondness for the ethereal beauty of moonstone. In my years at George Brown College and my own workshop, I've had the privilege of working with countless stones, learning their nuances, and mastering the techniques to showcase their inherent brilliance. This guide, a culmination of my experience, is designed to provide a comprehensive understanding of moonstone, from its geological origins to its optimal use in jewelry design and setting, always viewed through the lens of investment and enduring value.

Moonstone, a feldspar mineral with a captivating adularescence (the shimmering, billowy light that seems to float just beneath its surface), has captivated humanity for centuries. Its name, of course, speaks to its resemblance to the moon's soft glow, and ancient cultures often associated it with lunar deities and mystical properties. But beyond its romantic allure, moonstone presents a unique set of challenges and opportunities for the jeweler. Properly understood and skillfully handled, it can be transformed into investment-worthy pieces that appreciate not only in monetary value but also in sentimental significance.

The Geological Genesis of Moonstone

Before we delve into setting and design, it's crucial to understand the geological origins of moonstone. This understanding informs our appreciation for the stone's inherent characteristics and potential vulnerabilities.

Moonstone belongs to the feldspar group of minerals, specifically the alkali feldspars (orthoclase, albite, and microcline). Adularescence, the defining characteristic of moonstone, arises from a phenomenon known as *perthitic intergrowth*. This occurs when two feldspar minerals, typically orthoclase ($KAlSi_3O_8$) and albite ($NaAlSi_3O_8$), exsolve (separate) from a solid solution during cooling. These exsolved lamellae (thin, parallel layers) are of different refractive indices. As light enters the stone, it is scattered at these boundaries, producing the characteristic shimmering effect. The finer and more regular the lamellae, the more intense and desirable the adularescence.

While the above describes the most common type, it's important to recognize that other feldspars can also exhibit adularescence and be marketed as moonstone. These include:

• Rainbow Moonstone: Technically a variety of labradorite, another feldspar ($CaAl_2Si_2O_8$ to $NaAlSi_3O_8$). It displays a schiller effect, a broader iridescent play of color, rather than the singular, milky adularescence of true moonstone. While beautiful, it's crucial to distinguish it from true moonstone when assessing value.
• Adularia: A potassium-rich feldspar, considered by some to be the "true" moonstone. Fine quality adularia exhibits a bluish adularescence highly prized by collectors. Its chemical formula is $KAlSi_3O_8$.

Moonstone deposits are found in various locations around the world, including Sri Lanka, India, Myanmar (Burma), Madagascar, Tanzania, and the United States. The geographical origin can influence the color, clarity, and intensity of adularescence, and therefore, its value. Historically, Sri Lanka has been renowned for producing some of the finest quality moonstones with a captivating blue sheen.

Identifying Quality: The FCGmA Standard and Beyond

As an FCGmA, I adhere to a rigorous standard for verifying the authenticity and quality of gemstones, including moonstone. This involves a multi-faceted approach that incorporates visual inspection, microscopic analysis, and, in some cases, advanced gemmological testing.

When evaluating moonstone, consider the following factors:

• Adularescence: This is paramount. Look for a vibrant, floating light that appears to originate from within the stone. The color and intensity of the adularescence significantly impact value. Blue sheen is generally the most sought after, followed by silver and other hues. The adularescence should be visible from a wide range of viewing angles.
• Body Color: The ideal moonstone has a colorless to near-colorless body. This allows the adularescence to shine unimpeded. However, stones with subtle body colors, such as a light champagne or peach, can also be attractive, especially if the adularescence is exceptional.
• Clarity: Moonstone is rarely flawless. Inclusions are common, and some can even enhance the stone's character. However, large or dark inclusions that detract from the adularescence or compromise the stone's durability should be avoided. Small "centipede" inclusions (fine, parallel cracks) are relatively common and generally do not significantly affect value unless they are extensive.
• Cut: The cut is crucial for maximizing the adularescence. Cabochon cuts are the most common, as they best showcase the floating light effect. The cabochon should be symmetrical, well-polished, and free from significant blemishes. The height of the dome also affects the adularescence. A well-proportioned cabochon will exhibit a strong, even sheen across the entire surface.
• Size and Shape: Larger, high-quality moonstones are rarer and command higher prices. While round and oval cabochons are classic choices, moonstone is also found in a variety of other shapes, including freeform, pear, and cushion cuts. The choice of shape depends on the intended design and the natural characteristics of the stone.

Beware of imitations! Glass, synthetic spinels, and other materials can be used to mimic moonstone. Always purchase moonstone from a reputable source and, ideally, have it verified by a qualified gemmologist, particularly if you are investing in a significant piece.

Furthermore, the FCGmA standard emphasizes ethical sourcing. We must be mindful of the environmental and social impact of gemstone mining and strive to support responsible practices that benefit both the communities involved and the planet.

Durability Considerations

Moonstone, with a hardness of 6 to 6.5 on the Mohs scale, is relatively soft compared to other gemstones. This means it is susceptible to scratches and abrasions. This is a critical consideration when designing and setting moonstone jewelry.

Therefore, the design should minimize the stone's exposure to everyday wear and tear. Protective settings, such as bezels or partial bezels, are often preferred. Avoid designs where the moonstone is set flush with the surface of the jewelry, as this increases the risk of scratching.

Furthermore, moonstone is sensitive to heat and sudden temperature changes. Avoid exposing it to direct sunlight for prolonged periods or using harsh cleaning agents. Gentle cleaning with warm soapy water and a soft brush is the best approach.

Market Trends and Investment Potential

The demand for moonstone jewelry has fluctuated over time, but its timeless appeal ensures a consistent market. Factors influencing its price include:

• Rarity of High-Quality Stones: As with any gemstone, the scarcity of exceptional specimens drives up their value. Moonstones with strong blue adularescence, excellent clarity, and large size are particularly prized.
• Fashion Trends: The popularity of moonstone often aligns with broader fashion trends. For example, the resurgence of interest in bohemian and vintage styles has fueled demand for moonstone jewelry.
• Geopolitical Factors: Political instability or mining disruptions in major moonstone-producing regions can impact supply and, consequently, prices.
• Consumer Awareness: Educated consumers are more discerning and willing to pay a premium for high-quality, ethically sourced moonstones.

While moonstone may not offer the same level of speculative investment potential as, say, diamonds or colored gemstones like rubies or sapphires, it can still be a sound investment, particularly if you focus on acquiring well-made pieces featuring high-quality stones. A well-designed and crafted moonstone piece, especially one that showcases a rare and beautiful stone, can appreciate in value over time, both monetarily and sentimentally.

In the next part of this guide, we will delve into the practical aspects of setting moonstone, exploring various techniques and design considerations that ensure both the beauty and longevity of your creations. We will also discuss specific design strategies to maximize the adularescence and enhance the investment potential of moonstone jewelry.

Part 2: Setting and Design Considerations for Moonstone Jewelry

Welcome back. Now that we have a solid foundation in moonstone's geology, quality assessment, and market dynamics, let's move on to the practical aspects of designing and setting this captivating gem. Remember, our goal is not only to create beautiful jewelry but also to craft pieces that stand the test of time and retain, or even increase, their value.

The Master's Bench: Essential Moonstone Properties

Before we pick up our tools, let's review the key properties that will guide our setting and design decisions. This handy table provides a quick reference.

Property	Value	Notes
Refractive Index	1.518 - 1.526	This range is typical for orthoclase moonstone. Rainbow moonstone (labradorite) will have a slightly different range.
Mohs Hardness	6 - 6.5	Relatively soft; requires protective settings.
Specific Gravity	2.56 - 2.59	Useful for distinguishing from heavier simulants.

Choosing the Right Setting Style

Given moonstone's relative softness, the choice of setting is paramount. The primary objective is to protect the stone from scratches and impact while maximizing the display of its adularescence. Here are some of the most suitable options:

• Bezel Setting: This is often the *safest* and most *investment-conscious* choice. A bezel setting completely encircles the stone with a metal rim, providing excellent protection from all sides. The metal bezel can be plain, textured, or even feature decorative elements to enhance the overall design. Full bezels are excellent for rings and bracelets which endure high wear and tear.
• Partial Bezel Setting (Half Bezel): This offers a balance between protection and visibility. A partial bezel covers a portion of the stone's girdle, leaving the remaining area exposed. The exposed area can showcase more of the moonstone's body color and adularescence, but it also increases the risk of damage. Careful consideration of the design is crucial. Half bezels work well in earrings and pendants.
• Flush Setting (Gypsy Setting): While visually appealing, setting moonstone flush with the metal surface is *NOT recommended* due to its susceptibility to scratching. This setting offers minimal protection and is best avoided unless the piece is intended for very occasional wear.
• Prong Setting: While less protective than a bezel, prong settings can be used if the prongs are substantial and closely spaced. Ensure the prongs securely grip the stone and cover as much of the girdle as possible. Avoid sharp or pointed prongs, as they can chip the edges of the moonstone. Prong settings are common for Rainbow Moonstones to allow maximum light to enter the gemstone.
• Tension Setting: Tension settings are generally *unsuitable* for moonstone due to the pressure exerted on the stone. Moonstone's relative brittleness makes it vulnerable to cracking under tension.

When designing a setting, consider the following:

• Metal Choice: The metal should complement the moonstone's color and adularescence. Sterling silver and white gold are popular choices for showcasing the stone's cool, ethereal glow. Yellow gold can provide a warmer contrast. Consider the metal's hardness as well; platinum and harder gold alloys offer greater durability for the setting itself.
• Backing: A closed-back setting, where the back of the stone is covered with metal, can protect the stone from dirt and damage. However, an open-back setting can allow more light to enter the stone, enhancing its adularescence. The choice depends on the specific stone and the desired effect.
• Rivet Setting: Securing the moonstone without glue, by use of metal rivets. This will keep the gem from having any possibility of detaching from the jewelry.

Design Strategies to Maximize Adularescence

The design of the jewelry piece plays a crucial role in showcasing the moonstone's beauty. Here are some strategies to consider:

• Orientation: Carefully orient the moonstone in the setting to maximize the visibility of the adularescence. Experiment with different angles to find the position that produces the most vibrant and even sheen.
• Light Reflection: Incorporate reflective surfaces into the design to bounce light onto the moonstone. Polished metal surfaces or strategically placed facets can enhance the adularescence.
• Contrast: Use contrasting colors and textures to make the moonstone stand out. For example, setting a moonstone against a darkened or oxidized metal background can create a dramatic effect.
• Flow: The overall design should complement the fluid, ethereal quality of the moonstone. Consider incorporating curved lines and flowing shapes to echo the stone's inherent movement.
• Placement: For pendants, placing the moonstone close to the skin can enhance its glow, as body heat can slightly warm the stone and intensify its adularescence.

Bench Techniques: Handling Moonstone with Care

When working with moonstone, precision and delicacy are key. Here are some essential bench techniques:

• Gentle Filing and Polishing: Use fine-grit files and polishing compounds to avoid scratching the stone. Work slowly and carefully, and avoid excessive pressure.
• Low-Temperature Soldering: Moonstone is sensitive to heat, so use low-temperature solder and avoid prolonged exposure to the flame. Use heat-sink compounds to protect the stone from heat damage.
• Careful Stone Setting: When setting the stone, use gentle, even pressure to avoid cracking or chipping it. Ensure the setting is snug but not overly tight.
• Avoiding Abrasives: When polishing the jewelry, protect the moonstone from abrasive compounds. Mask the stone with tape or use a specialized polishing technique that avoids contact with the stone.

Reza’s Authentication Tip

In my experience, a quick way to spot glass imitations of moonstone is by observing the movement of the light. True moonstone exhibits a billowy, almost three-dimensional adularescence that seems to float within the stone. Glass imitations often display a surface sheen that lacks depth and appears static. Also, look closely for air bubbles, which are rarely found in natural moonstone. This is not a foolproof test, but it often gives me an initial indication of authenticity.

Ethical Sourcing and Sustainability

As responsible jewelers, we must prioritize ethical sourcing and sustainable practices. Inquire about the origin of your moonstones and support suppliers who adhere to fair labor standards and environmentally responsible mining practices. Consider using recycled metals and minimizing waste in your production processes. By embracing ethical and sustainable practices, we can contribute to a more just and environmentally conscious jewelry industry.

Beyond the Basics: Elevating Moonstone Jewelry to Investment Grade

To create moonstone jewelry that transcends fleeting trends and becomes a lasting investment, consider these advanced strategies:

• Pairing with Precious Gemstones: Combining moonstone with diamonds, sapphires, or other precious gemstones can elevate the piece's value and appeal. Select gemstones that complement the moonstone's color and adularescence.
• Limited Edition Designs: Creating limited edition pieces with unique designs can enhance their collectibility and investment potential. Number and sign each piece to increase its provenance.
• Commissioned Pieces: Working directly with clients to create custom moonstone jewelry allows you to tailor the design to their specific preferences and create a truly unique and valuable piece.
• Documented Provenance: Maintaining detailed records of the moonstone's origin, quality, and design can enhance its long-term value. Provide certificates of authenticity and appraisals from reputable gemmologists.

By combining your artistic skills with a thorough understanding of moonstone's properties and market dynamics, you can create jewelry that is not only beautiful but also a sound investment for your clients. Remember, the key to success is to prioritize quality, craftsmanship, and ethical sourcing.

Conclusion

The information in this guide should help you in designing, sourcing, and authenticating moonstones. We hope you are now prepared to work with moonstones and develop gorgeous jewelry.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

1. Webster, Robert. Gems: Their Sources, Descriptions and Identification. 5th ed. London: Butterworth-Heinemann, 1994.
2. Liddicoat, Richard T. Handbook of Gem Identification. 12th ed. Santa Monica, CA: Gemological Institute of America, 1989.
3. Nassau, Kurt. Gemstone Enhancement. 2nd ed. Woburn, MA: Butterworth-Heinemann, 1994.
4. O'Donoghue, Michael. Gems. 6th ed. London: Butterworth-Heinemann, 2006.
5. Reza Gem Collection Research Lab. Internal reports and data, 2023.

---