Moonstone Value Factors: Reza Piroznia’s Framework for Assessing Schiller and Bodycolor

I am Reza Piroznia, FCGmA—Master Artisan, Certified Gemmologist. Part of our Ultimate Moonstone Guide. Identifying moonstone's characteristic features is crucial for valuation, and this analysis builds upon the comprehensive insights in our Moonstone master guide.

This first part of the guide will lay the groundwork for a deeper understanding of these factors, starting with a foundational look at what moonstone *is* and why it exhibits the phenomena that make it so prized.

Understanding Moonstone: A Feldspar Gem

Before we delve into assessing schiller and bodycolor, let's establish a solid understanding of moonstone itself. Moonstone is, at its heart, a feldspar mineral. Feldspars are a group of rock-forming tectosilicate minerals that make up over 50% of the Earth's crust. The specific feldspars that give us moonstone are orthoclase ($KAlSi_3O_8$) and albite ($NaAlSi_3O_8$). These minerals are not always present in isolation; more often than not, they form what we call a solid solution.

This solid solution manifests within moonstone as alternating layers, or lamellae, of orthoclase and albite. These layers are microscopic in scale, and it's their interaction with light that creates the magic we know as schiller, also sometimes called adularescence.

The Cause of Schiller: A Deeper Look

Schiller, that ethereal glow that seems to emanate from within the stone, isn't simply a reflection of light. It's a phenomenon of interference and scattering. Light enters the moonstone and encounters these alternating layers of orthoclase and albite. Because these layers have slightly different refractive indices (a measure of how much light bends when passing through a material), a portion of the light is reflected at each interface. These reflected rays interfere with each other, either constructively (reinforcing each other) or destructively (cancelling each other out). Constructive interference leads to the appearance of that characteristic shimmering effect, while destructive interference is not usually seen.

The thickness and regularity of these layers are crucial. If the layers are too thick or too irregular, the schiller will be weak or nonexistent. Ideally, the layers should be roughly the same size as the wavelengths of visible light. This is why understanding the micro-structure is essential to appreciate schiller. Consider it like the precise grooves on a vinyl record or the diffraction grating in a spectrometer; the regularity is what produces the effect we want.

Defining Schiller: Quality and Characteristics

Now that we understand the *cause* of schiller, let's define what constitutes *good* schiller. When I assess schiller quality as an FCGmA, I consider several key characteristics:

• Intensity: How strong is the glow? A vibrant, noticeable schiller is more desirable than a faint one.
• Coverage: How much of the stone's surface exhibits schiller? A schiller that covers the entire face of the gem is generally preferred.
• Color: The color of the schiller itself can vary. The most common and highly valued color is blue, referred to as “blue sheen”. Other colors, like silver, white, or even yellow, can also occur. While blue is the most prized, the intensity and coverage are always more important. A strong white sheen is more valuable than a weak blue sheen.
• Movement: Does the schiller “roll” or shift across the surface of the stone as it's tilted? Good schiller should exhibit a dynamic, almost fluid-like movement. I sometimes compare it to the shimmer on the surface of water under moonlight.
• Clarity/Transparency: It's important to realize that there's a trade-off sometimes. A highly transparent stone might exhibit less schiller, while a slightly more translucent stone might show a more intense schiller. It is best if there is high transparency with a high sheen.

When assessing schiller, I use a standardized lighting environment. Diffuse, even lighting is ideal, as it allows the subtle nuances of the schiller to be observed without harsh shadows or reflections. Direct sunlight can sometimes overwhelm the schiller, making it difficult to accurately assess its quality.

Bodycolor: The Foundation of the Gem

While schiller is the defining characteristic of moonstone, the bodycolor of the stone plays a significant role in its overall value and desirability. Bodycolor refers to the inherent color of the moonstone when viewed without the influence of schiller. The term 'bodycolor' is analogous to a 'background colour' or 'base colour' and is commonly used within the gemmological sciences.

Moonstone can occur in a range of bodycolors, from colorless to white, gray, brown, yellow, orange, green, or even pink. The presence of trace elements within the crystal structure is typically responsible for these variations in color.

Factors Influencing Bodycolor Value

The value of a particular bodycolor depends on several factors, including:

• Rarity: Some bodycolors are rarer than others. For example, highly saturated orange, green, or pink moonstones are less common than colorless or white moonstones.
• Clarity: The clarity of the bodycolor is crucial. A hazy or cloudy bodycolor will detract from the overall beauty of the stone. A clear, transparent bodycolor is highly desirable.
• Saturation: The intensity or depth of the color is also important. A richly saturated color is generally more valuable than a pale or muted color.
• Interaction with Schiller: The interplay between the bodycolor and the schiller is a critical factor. A complementary bodycolor can enhance the beauty of the schiller, while a clashing bodycolor can detract from it. For instance, the blue sheen on a colorless body makes the blue stand out even more.

Assessing Bodycolor: Practical Considerations

When assessing bodycolor, I use a similar approach to assessing schiller. I use a standardized lighting environment and a neutral background. This helps to minimize any external influences on the perceived color. I also compare the moonstone to a set of standard color references to ensure consistency in my evaluation.

It is important to consider the size and cutting style of the moonstone when assessing bodycolor. Larger stones will typically exhibit a more intense bodycolor than smaller stones. The cutting style can also affect the perceived color, as different facets can reflect and refract light in different ways.

The FCGmA Standard: A Commitment to Accuracy

As an FCGmA, I adhere to the highest standards of gemmological practice. This includes using calibrated instruments, employing standardized lighting conditions, and relying on my extensive experience to accurately assess the quality of moonstones. The FCGmA designation signifies a commitment to ethical and objective gemmological evaluations. When you see the FCGmA designation, you know that the evaluation has been carried out by a professional who has met rigorous standards of competence and integrity. This includes a deep understanding of gem treatments, synthetics, and imitations.

By following these guidelines, we can ensure that our assessment of moonstone is as objective and accurate as possible.

Conclusion to Part 1

In this first part of our guide, we have laid the foundation for understanding the two primary value factors in moonstone: schiller and bodycolor. We explored the physical causes of schiller and discussed the characteristics that define its quality. We also examined the role of bodycolor and the factors that influence its value. In the next part, we'll delve deeper into the interplay between schiller and bodycolor and explore the impact of cutting and other factors on overall moonstone value. Thank you for joining me, and I look forward to continuing this journey with you.

Moonstone Value Factors: Reza Piroznia’s Framework for Assessing Schiller and Bodycolor - Part 2

Welcome back, fellow gem enthusiasts, to the second part of our comprehensive guide on moonstone valuation. In Part 1, we established a foundation for understanding schiller and bodycolor, the two crucial value factors in moonstone assessment. We delved into the science behind schiller, explored the characteristics of good schiller, and examined the influence of bodycolor on a moonstone’s overall desirability. Now, we will explore the interplay between these two factors, discuss the impact of cutting and other considerations on moonstone value, and provide practical insights from my experience at the bench.

The Interplay Between Schiller and Bodycolor

As we established in Part 1, schiller and bodycolor are not independent variables; they exist in a dynamic relationship, each influencing the perception and value of the other. The most exquisite moonstones are those where these two factors complement and enhance one another. For instance, a vivid blue schiller, sometimes termed “blue sheen,” against a colorless or slightly milky bodycolor creates a striking contrast that significantly increases its value. The colorless background allows the blue to truly 'pop', making it appear more intense and vibrant.

Conversely, a strong yellow bodycolor might subdue a weaker blue schiller, making it less noticeable. However, that same yellow bodycolor could harmonize beautifully with a silver or gold schiller, creating a warm and inviting aesthetic. The key is balance and harmony. As a Master Artisan, I often spend considerable time experimenting with different lighting and viewing angles to understand how schiller and bodycolor interact within a particular stone. This intuitive understanding comes from years of experience, but it’s something you can develop with careful observation and practice.

Consider also the opacity and transparency of the bodycolor. A highly transparent bodycolor might allow a deep, internal schiller to shine through brilliantly. However, a slightly translucent bodycolor, often described as "milky," can diffuse the light and create a softer, more ethereal schiller effect. Neither is inherently "better" than the other; it depends on the specific characteristics of the stone and the desired aesthetic.

The Impact of Cutting on Moonstone Value

The cut of a moonstone is paramount in showcasing its schiller and bodycolor to their fullest potential. A well-cut moonstone will maximize the intensity, coverage, and movement of its schiller, while also highlighting the beauty of its bodycolor. Poor cutting, on the other hand, can diminish or even eliminate these qualities. As a Master Artisan, I've seen countless examples of potentially stunning moonstones that were rendered mediocre by poor cutting decisions.

The most common and effective cut for moonstones is the cabochon. This smooth, domed shape allows light to enter the stone and interact with the layered structure, creating the characteristic schiller effect. The height and curvature of the cabochon are crucial. A cabochon that is too flat may not adequately capture and reflect light, resulting in a weak schiller. A cabochon that is too high can create undesirable internal reflections and shadows, obscuring the schiller.

The orientation of the cabochon is also critical. The cutter must carefully align the cut with the layered structure of the moonstone to maximize the schiller effect. If the cut is misaligned, the schiller may be uneven or nonexistent. I often use a polariscope to help me identify the optimal cutting orientation before even touching the rough stone.

While cabochons are the most common cut, other cuts, such as faceted cuts, are occasionally used for moonstones, especially when the bodycolor is particularly appealing. However, faceting moonstone is a risky proposition, as it can easily diminish or eliminate the schiller effect. It requires a skilled lapidary with a deep understanding of moonstone's optical properties.

Other Factors Influencing Moonstone Value

Beyond schiller, bodycolor, and cutting, several other factors can influence moonstone value:

• Size: Larger moonstones are generally more valuable than smaller ones, all other factors being equal. This is because larger stones are rarer and can showcase schiller and bodycolor more effectively.
• Clarity: Inclusions, or internal imperfections, can detract from the beauty and value of a moonstone. However, some inclusions, such as needle-like inclusions of goethite, can actually enhance the schiller effect by creating additional scattering of light.
• Origin: Historically, certain localities have been known for producing high-quality moonstones. For instance, Sri Lanka (formerly Ceylon) has long been renowned for its blue-sheen moonstones. While origin can influence value, it is ultimately the quality of the individual stone that matters most.
• Treatments: Moonstones are sometimes treated to enhance their color or clarity. Dyeing and coating are common treatments for moonstones. It is crucial to disclose any treatments to the buyer, as they can significantly affect the value of the stone.

The Master's Bench: Key Properties of Moonstone

Here are some key properties of moonstone that I find myself consulting regularly at my bench:

Property	Value
Refractive Index	1.518 - 1.526
Mohs Hardness	6 - 6.5
Specific Gravity	2.56 - 2.59

Reza’s Authentication Tip

Over the years, I've seen numerous attempts to imitate moonstone. One trick I've noticed is the use of iridescent glass or plastic. These imitations often exhibit a rainbow-like sheen that is too uniform and artificial-looking compared to genuine moonstone's schiller. Real moonstone schiller shifts subtly as you rotate the stone, revealing various tones of blue or white, not a static rainbow. Also, observe closely with a loupe: Imitations often have telltale bubbles. Remember, genuine moonstone is a natural mineral formed under immense pressure. These characteristics are difficult to convincingly replicate. Trust your instincts and scrutinize the sheen; a true gem has subtle variations in the schiller’s intensity.

The Importance of Ethical Sourcing

As consumers, we have a responsibility to ensure that the gemstones we purchase are ethically sourced. This means supporting suppliers who adhere to fair labor practices, protect the environment, and avoid conflict zones. Look for suppliers who are transparent about their sourcing practices and who are committed to responsible gemmology. Supporting ethical sourcing ensures that the beauty of moonstone doesn’t come at the cost of human suffering or environmental degradation. As an FCGmA, I always advise my clients to make informed decisions regarding gem origins.

Conclusion to Part 2

In this second part of our guide, we have explored the interplay between schiller and bodycolor, examined the impact of cutting and other factors on moonstone value, and provided practical tips from my experience as a Master Artisan and Certified Gemmologist. By understanding these factors, you can make more informed decisions when buying, selling, or simply appreciating moonstones. Remember, the true value of a moonstone lies not only in its objective qualities but also in its unique beauty and the story it tells. Keep an eye out for future instalments of this guide where we'll tackle more advanced topics. Thank you for joining me on this journey of gemmological discovery.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

1. Nassau, Kurt. Gemstone Enhancement. Butterworth-Heinemann, 1994.
2. Read, Peter G. Gemmology. Butterworth-Heinemann, 2005.
3. Liddicoat, Richard T. Handbook of Gem Identification. Gemological Institute of America, 1989.
4. Sinkankas, John. Gemstones of North America. Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1976.
5. Reza Gem Collection Research Lab. Internal Studies on Moonstone Adularescence. Unpublished Data, 2023.

---